3/5 ⭐
Our Rogue Fates by Sarah Glen Marsh
Well, this was certainly… an experience. After seeing all the glowing comparisons to Lord of the Rings and Critical Role, I was expecting something with a bit more substance than what Our Rogue Fates delivered.
Look, I get it. Sarah Glenn Marsh was clearly going for that cozy fantasy adventure vibe with a side of romantic tension. But here’s the thing: when your entire plot hinges on a treasure hunt that feels more like an afterthought, and your “enemies-to-lovers” arc is really just “friends who had a misunderstanding and spent years being dramatic about it,” you’re not exactly breaking new ground.
Griff and Mal’s relationship felt frustratingly shallow for two people supposedly harboring years of complex emotions. Instead of getting genuine character development, we’re treated to endless circular conversations about their mysterious past conflict that honestly wasn’t worth all the buildup once revealed. Meanwhile, poor Alys is just… there? Tagging along like the world’s most patient third wheel while these two work through their feelings.
All in all, Our Rogue Fates isn’t terrible, but it’s disappointingly mediocre for something that promised so much adventure and heart. I really wanted to give it two stars but Alys kinda saved the day here. Save your time for something that actually delivers on its ambitious comparisons.
Thank you NetGalley and Alcove Press for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Rin's Reads 
Leave a comment